Black women and ‘The Swirl’
Yeah, it’s about that time. Time that I dealt with the sensitive issue (to a lot of people) of interracial dating/marriage, and more specifically, how black women approach it. Most black women obviously take issue to seeing a black man with a white woman, and there are several reasons why, but here are a couple that I’ve gathered and my personal responses to each:
-
They’re taking all of our men. Well, who made them “your men” to begin with? I know that sounds a little harsh, but in our society, we form our own social groups. For a while, there was a “black” social group based on our common treatment from outside groups. Nowadays these social groups are based on different criteria, and not just skin color. I just think it’s incorrect to assume that just because someone has darker skin, that they automatically have the same education, culture, listen to the same music, have the same faith, and are generally like you. I think that’s a terrible assumption to make in 2008. Some blacks have more in common with whites they grew up with than other blacks from another neighborhood (and for people to think there’s something wrong with that is a slap in the face to MLK)……hence my overall point that you can tell less and less about a person based on skin color nowadays. It wasn’t like this 100 years ago.
-
If they’re dating the white women, what are we supposed to do? It’s a phenomenon that’s definitely worth looking into (the effects of black men dating outside the race and how black women are left with fewer mates), but I’ll never agree that you should choose a partner based on what happens to the woman you did not choose. I understand the plight of the black woman…to a certain extent. I understand that there is a larger culture gap between black women and non-black men then there is between black men and non-black women, but this has more to do with an issue with black women, and not that there’s somehow a problem with what black men are doing.
Why does there have to be a problem with a black man who is more open to other cultures? Why is there something wrong with a man who can move through various cultural circles with relative ease? I fail to see this as a problem. I see it more of an issue that black women have allowed themselves to remain cutoff from other cultures and people that they share nothing in common with. And I’m not saying that it’s entirely black women’s fault…but if there’s anything that we’ve learned from mother nature, it’s that she likes diversity, and I don’t think someone with diverse taste has a “problem”.
-
Black men are running away from the black community. Well, like I’ve said in other posts, if I’m running away from the black community, then I’m running away from every community. I don’t run from anybody or anything. I don’t care to get caught up in this charade of race, so why would I care about running away from a community I don’t think actually exists anyway? We create our own communities, and I base them on family and those that are similar in culture, not skin color. It just so happens that my family is either high yella or darker skinned, so they are a part of my community. There are others that I am not related to that share my interests and are great all around people, so I have accepted them into my community as well. I will never run away from a community that I call home. This includes black, white, asian, latino, whatever kind of people. Communities based solely on skin color or physical characteristics are foolish, and I want no part of them anyway. Count me out of that ridiculousness…please.
-
They see it as a personal attack on black women. Again, as harsh as it may sound, this is an issue with black women, not black men. If you feel attacked by something as natural as another man being attracted to another woman who doesn’t have the same skin color you do, then that’s on you. I’d love to help out with fixing this problem, but it’s not going to be in the form of compromising who I’m attracted to.
I certainly mean no harm to anyone with my decision of whom I decide to start a family with, but this stuff about black men hurting black women just because they’re naturally attracted to all types of women is craziness. It’s equivalent to getting angry with a gay guy for being gay. It’s natural (as much as some of you disagree, but you should pick up a book on the issue other than the bible before making that assumption) to be gay for some people just as it’s natural for black men to be attracted to women that don’t look like their mother.
-
They think every black man that is with a white woman exclusively dates white women. I think this issue comes down to statistics. Whites make up like 70% or something of the US population compared to like 11% with blacks. If a black man found all women equally attractive, don’t you think the odds of him being with a white woman outweigh being with any other “race”?
I find all types of different women attractive regardless of skin tone. Being that I grew up around both white and black folk, I’ve adapted a culture somewhere in the middle where black folks would say I don’t “act black”, and the white folks would say I don’t “act white”. So, my taste in women deals more with someone who is more like me and not “like a color”.
For me personally, given that I’m not religious and don’t care about “being black” (or conversely “being white” for that matter), a lot of black women are automatically disqualified from my rolodex of potential mates. Race and god are huge factors in the lives of black women, and I’m just not of that mold. Not that there aren’t black women that aren’t like me out there, but I’m not going to sit on my thumbs waiting for her to appear when I’ve got a perfect life mate right in front of me. Excuse me while I find more important things in a potential life mate than the color of her skin or hair.
This has been a touchy subject for a while in this world, this country, and my family for quite some time now. With everything, I urge people to talk about this more. If you feel like someone is wrong for dating someone else, by all means, talk about it. But don’t expect me to feel sorry for a woman who makes the conscious decision to shut herself off to dating men of other cultures. If you make that decision, then live with it. Don’t take it out on me because I’m not as narrow minded.
There’s far too much beauty in this world to limit yourself to one pocket of our species. Explore the world, open yourself up to it and you might just find something you like…or dare I say love.
No related posts.












All valid points, but there are a lot of black guys that like white women. I can’t explain ,I am a white guy. Me personally I am attracted to black women because I have always been surrounded by white chics. But that works both ways. Some people develop there “type” based on what they are around growing up. While others want the complete opposite of what they have seen while growing up.
Yeah. We’re all human beings and wired differently. I just think it’s damn absurd to suggest something is “wrong” with someone just because they are attracted to someone “outside the race”. I’m beginning to think people actually enjoy complicating their lives.
I think I enjoy your blog most when you tackle sensitive race issues that people don’t like to talk about. How about a post on the stereotypical angry/proud black dragon woman? I.E. Naymund’s mom in season 4 of the greatest show ever. I seem to have a knack for encountering these types in St. Louis. And they pretty much always own me.
Thanks Hagana. I’ll see if I can bring it up somehow, without phrasing it exactly like you have…my aim is to tackle the issues and not offend people that are undeserving. I think a lot of innocent black women would take offense to labeling other black women “dragons”…you know what I mean? I’ll definitely bring it up though.
wow… excellent post, Zoc.
How about you, do you date white women, would you marry a white woman…. this is a profound topic, there should be more opinions, I wonder if the sisters like this point of view?
Yes, my fiance is white.
I’d love to get black women more involved in this topic. It’s a new site and it’s been slow at getting publicized. You’re more than welcome to circulate the article though!
are you really looking for opinions on this subject, or perhaps the opportunity to slay another gladiator in an effort to stack them under your soapbox?
if your position is so flawless, it seems “thou doth protest too much” (and too loudly, and too strident, and too long)
to many, this is a hurtful, sensitive subject. a constant reminder on lonely weekends. that means, no dates, no courtship, no fun, no phone calls, no engagements, no weddings, no relationships, no family. it is a crushingly serious subject to those who go through this experience. and the impact on our community is, and will continue to be, staggering.
so be firm in your own conviction–whatever that may be (oh raceless one). ride your wave. but for the rest of us, as lennon so profoundly said, let it be.
I’d like to first welcome you to the site and thank you for your comment. I certainly welcome opposing views, since this is essentially what this site is for: to discuss sensitive issues and hopefully make some sense of them.
Perhaps we should find out why this is such a sensitive subject.
Like I said in the post, I don’t believe anyone should refrain from dating someone based on the impact of the mate they didn’t choose. Saying black men shouldn’t date white women because of the impact it has on black women is pretty nonsensical to me. If there was something inherently wrong with dating white women, you may have a point, but there’s nothing wrong with finding someone you love of a different skin color.
Placing the responsibility on black men for black women’s loneliness is where our problems begin….not with black men and their less discriminatory taste in women. If you’re unhappy in your life, take some responsibility and stop blaming others for your condition.
If you have anything specific you’d like to discuss, please let me know. It just seems like you’re on the defense here rather than addressing the actual issue.
in response to your post (being careful not to slip on all this soap), it is a sensitive subject because it goes to the heart of all that matters: human relationships. to have women “take some responsibility and stop blaming others” is emotionless and indicative of a lack of perspective on the entire situation. it’s a matter, as native americans have said, of being able to “walk a mile in their moccasins”. there is a “distance”, a detachment, you portray which is, frankly, frightening.
it is short-sighted to believe that the impact is only being felt by black women. don’t diminish the perspective of young black males who are being brought up in less than stellar circumstances in a household with no male (black or otherwise). don’t think that young males of any race (yes, that hated word) are not culturally attuned to their fathers. the lack of one is devastating. you need to see someone who looks like you. i can only say to you, query someone who knows about the subject to determine how important it is.
in addition, the issue takes on significance because of the sheer numbers involved. if it were isolated, in the scheme of things, it just wouldn’t matter. most isolated things don’t. but when it threatens the very survival of a people–their place in history, their world standing, their own sense of self–you’ve got a situation of major proportions.
you seem very eager to defend your position, at the expense of “attacking” black women. especially when no defense is needed. do what you do. dance to the music, but pay the piper. black women will not always be the ones to extract payment, as you will soon find out, if you haven’t already. and don’t make the mistake that black women are the only ones with opinions on this issue. their reactions can be inocuous–a dirty look, at best.
and lastly, please note that far more dangerous and entrenched opinions are held by others. others that are far more powerful than a lonely black woman.
I don’t think asking people to take responsibility is emotionless at all. If I were a white man asking a freed black slave to accept responsibility for his circumstance, then that’s a situation that calls for some further understanding and compassion…..but black men are not the oppressing white men you make us out to be. Those that find non-black mates have done nothing wrong.
Yes, there is a bit of a situation here with black women and the shrinking pool of available black men. If you’d like to discuss a remedy to this issue, I’m willing and able, but I have a hard time understanding how black men should be implicated in any way.
By the way, you should take a look at my post Prison, cancer, and kids that don’t talk so good.
Overall, I’m confused what point you’re trying to make. I think you’re taking issue with me bringing this issue up AT ALL. Please understand that I’m not some preacher trying to convert people. I enjoy candid discussion that will allow us to better understand one another. If you would like to discuss this any further, I would be more than happy to create a discussion topic in my forum if you’re up to it. Please reply in the comments if you’re interested.
I am a black woman and I am thinking like the other person let it go, especially since your not even having to deal with it at this point.
since im here I may as well speak on it. I don’t date outside my race simply because I haven’t found a white guy or “other” that appeals to me as much as I would like. Its just something about the black man that turns me on how he spits game, how he dresses, how he walks and talks. I don’t care what other race you are it just doesn’t compare(for me). I wouldn’t go as far to blame black men for dating other races because I could do the same if I wanted to. since I chose not to the numbers aren’t always going to be in my favor for getting that good black man. I keep looking for him and if i get to a point like awww dang I just can’t look no more then i will consider dating outside of that right now guess what I’m good!!!
I have two opposing views on this.
Position A) There is only one race; Human. And we are all free. We all ave the right to the persuit of happiness, right? If black women are lonely sitting by a phone that does not ring, then they can pick up the phone and call some one! It’s not the responsibility of black men to make all the black women happy.
Position B) The only reason that a black guy can date a white woman, without getting lynched, is because the black ‘race’ banded together and fought for equality.
Mikki, I think the fact that the culture gap is so wide between black women and white men is why this is such a big issue for black women. It’s not necessarily anyone’s ‘fault’ that the gap is so large, but if more black women had more in common with white men, I doubt as many black women would care, since they would have a larger pool of men to choose from.
Brian, good stuff. That’s another thing I find interesting is that people fought for equality in the 50s and 60s, and now that we’re equal enough to marry one another, people are seemingly fighting for inequality again. You can’t preach equality and separation at the same time.
The fact that we are still so caught up this this separation of the races is a sad indictment of humanity.
I am a woman who happens to be included in the category of ‘black’ and from my perspective your race tells me very little about you as a person.
I don’t care what ‘colour’ you are – I’m more interested in your personality, whether or not you are sheep and follow the crowd and such things.
I have said this before, but the future history will look back on this period and view this era as the real dark ages. I wonder when people will wake up?
Zaki, I salute you for raising this topic and laying your cards so visibly on the table. Ignorance is rife and I’m glad you have chosen not to make it a feature of your life. Thanks to all those contributors who have chosen to remove the blinkers society has placed on the masses.
A really great site, Zaki. Hard work well done!
Thank you so much for your comment Zee. I think we’ll all eventually wake up, but it’s going to take people like ourselves to continue to the open dialog about these sort of topics. It’s a slow process, and I think we’ll naturally get there, but talking about it more just speeds up the process.
Zaki,
I have had a recent experience commenting on a blog by a black woman who feels she has, or so it seems to me, a duty to focus on black on black relationships. The tone of this site is so negative especially as this woman is ‘biracial’ (her description) with a white biological parent. Her premise is that black people having relationships outside her race can be classified as ‘denaturing’ themselves (the black people that is).
Her partner jumped to her defence and wrote a rather pointless, robust response to my dissenting comments and although I have a whole ream of words ready – I just cannot be bothered to waste another minute of my time! Time where I can be reading inspiring works, perusing other blogs, playing with my animals, enjoying the sunsets and just having fun!
Some people just won’t get it and as I am not searching for a ‘grouphug/lovefest’ from people on the web there comes a point where you just leave people to wallow in their unhappy ignorance.
Zaki, keep on writing. Keep on living your life for you. This is it, no other to come – so why not forget those who berate you for your choice of who to love.
Regards,
Zee.
As always, thanks for the kind words Zee! I’m getting to see more and more each day that most people are incredibly damaged and delusional. It’s a constant battle between our emotions and logic….and I think people like the ones you described above are incredibly emotional and refuse to logically deal with the absurdity of racial designations.
Not much we can do at this point outside of discussion and taking those trips to the beach so we don’t lose our minds
Ok, so I am a bit lit on this post. but I must comment:
It is odd how you say you don’t care about being Black. What do you consider yourself to be? I am sorry to have to be the barer of “bad” news (perhaps), but you are black, regardless of what you think you are, that is how you are seen. So not caring about being black seems to be more of a hinderance than anything. And you are probably right. That is what may exclude Black women from your “rolodex”. Black women, when with a man especially a Black man, will probably want just that. Being Black is so much more than a color, in fact, it is to me a political statement and culture more than anything else. But I digress. And why is it that to be with a white woman, you must not care about YOUR culture. There are white men that date black women and maintain their identity (there are those that don’t), and the same thing goes for Black women with white men. Anytime you feel the need to give up your being to be with someone, I think, calls for some serious introspection.
What culture do you share with white women? I am just curious.
Next, you dont think the black community exists? It is that sort of thinking that will surely be the demise of it. It is REAL. It exists. When you are like me, who is now far removed from any real black community (to no fault of my own), and you appreciate it for what is is and how it can shape you, you miss it. How can it not exist? There are communities for all ethnicities. And there should be. I am not the one who believes in being color-less. That’s a cop of. And I am someone who by pure definition, could be called “mulit-racial. But in my eyes, and the eyes of everyone, I am Black. I accept them, and I have no qualms with it. I would hope neither would anyone else.
And I think when folks say that you are “running away” from the community, they may mean just that. In a world where there are far more black women role models than black men for these young black boys, it hurts when our men leave. This is reality. I have plenty of girlfriends who are attractive, successful, beyond intelligent, and in certain places, black men won’t look twice at them. But let a woman of another face walk by, specifically white women, and they lose their minds. My friends are flabbergasted by this trend, and so am I. When this occurs, it seems to be a preference, not just ” I am attracted to a women”. It becomes “I am attracted to this type of woman.” which is fine But when questioned as to why that is the case, they struggle for an aswer.
We all should be aware of the history between black men and white women. This is why, some love them, and some black men won’t even be seen alone with one. This is reality. How we choose to deal with that history, is what separates these men.
This has nothing to with the strugle for equality, or with the ability of black women to date outside our race. Because trust me, I have personally done it, and had the opportunity to do so. It is about the symbolism of it. For instance, why is it that our men of power (excluding President Obama and some choice others), make it and then ditch their past black female counterparts, and date white women? What changes that makes them be able identify more with them? Is it the money or assumed prestige? The fact that having a white woman on your arm looks better than having a black woman in that same position? I have my own opinions on this, I would like to hear from those who fit that profile.
It should not be hard for a black man to understand how a black woman feels when he dates someone different. And to be honest, it goes both ways. Some black MUST comment when he sees a sister with someone else.
PS: another part of the struggle of the Civil Rights Era, one part that is surely overlooked, is the fight for us to be able to take pride openly in ourselves, in our culture, without having to conform to the Americanized, Euro-centric view of self. You will find this more with Malcolm X, H. Newton, and the Pan-Africanists.
Peace and Blessings.
Thanks for the comment
Well, I’ve written a couple posts on this very subject:
Why should I call myself black?
Racelessness for Dummies…and Smarties too
In short, I consider myself a human being regardless of what others may call me. I’m well aware that others see me as black and I adjust my life accordingly in that respect, but that has nothing to do with the way I see myself…and I’ve made the decision that race is superficial and was created by folks with a specific agenda to promote their race as supreme, making all others inferior. It helped them to justify slavery and other genocidal atrocities. No one wants to stop and think about why they do what they do…well I have, and I’ve realized being that concerned about the color of your skin is unnecessary. If someone sees me as an asshole, does that mean I should identify myself as an asshole? Hell no. I define who I am to myself, but since I see no point in giving a definition to who I am, I’ll just be who I am and leave it at that.
Exactly. We’ve got it mixed up where someone that isn’t caught up in the superficiality of race is vilified while the narrow-minded black man is lauded. Race is a social construct. It was created by some white folks hundreds of years ago for a specific purpose: to justify their ridiculousness. A lot of people realize this and have made the decision to not base their life decisions on the color of one’s skin or their common ancestry. If that’s important to you, then that’s your thing. Just sit down and think about WHY it’s important to you though.
First of all, what exactly is culture to you? Because you’re born with black skin, does that mean you HAVE to do as the other dark skinned people do? Actually think about this for a moment. I get more into this in the posts I’ve listed above, but now in 2009, skin color is becoming less and less a factor in determining social class, what music you listen to, your dialect, where you’re from, etc etc. Your culture is defined more by your surroundings than your phenotype. If you’re born black, that doesn’t mean you’ll automatically listen to Hip Hop or R&B. It doesn’t mean you’ll like chitlins or black eyed peas. It doesn’t really mean anything other than that other people will see you as a black person….and that’s not even guaranteed since less and less people are caring about race nowadays anyway.
I listen to R&B, love sports, enjoy web development and love my family….that’s my “culture”. Nowhere in there does race play a factor. When I chose my mate, it was someone that shared similar interests of mine, and not that she had a specific skin color. Back in the day during slavery and even segregation, it just so happened that skin color determined what you did, what you listed to, and who you hung around….so with damn near 100% certainty, the only people you would find things in common with were going to have the same skin color as you. Nowadays we’re not AS segregated and you may find company with all different sort of people. White people listen to rap and black people listen to country. It’s called diversity. We’re becoming more similar as a group and finding more common ground than 100 years ago. Our cultures are blurring and there’s nothing wrong with that.
You may enjoy a more specific “black culture”, but I embrace many cultures, including black culture. I can appreciate nearly every musical genre: R&B, hip hop, pop, country, jazz, classical, bluegrass, rap, gospel (yes gospel), rock, and the list goes on. I have embraced people of all backgrounds as my friend and can relate to most people on one level or another based on my diverse upbringing: You can read more about it here.
Well, I just as I grew up around black folks, I grew up around white folks too. I went to elementary school from 2nd to 6th grades where blacks were about 90%, to a private school from 7th to 9th where blacks were about 5%, if that. I got an appreciation for people absent of their race. I learned that assholes and good people come in all colors.
More to your question, I don’t need to have a shared history with someone to have something in common with them. If you want to go into common ancestry, you can trace us back to a common ancestor whether you believe in Adam and Eve or evolution. We’re human beings and you can either look at someone with lighter skin as different from you because of something their ancestors may or may not have done….or you can focus on our similarities. I choose the latter and choose my friends by our common interests: sports, music, entertainment, kindness, etc. In that respect, I have quite a lot in common with EVERYONE regardless of race.
Sure, the black community exists to people that care about race-based communities. I personally don’t concern myself with race to that extent to say I belong to a group of people with similar skin color. I understood why people did that 200 years ago, or even 50, but today, there simply is no reason to associate with people simply because they are black. Skin color is becoming less and less a factor in determining anything about a person.
Again, I’m simply not going to acknowledge someone saying I’m running away from a community that shouldn’t exist in 2009. What exactly is this “black community”? Just a group of black people? Why are we discriminating this way in 2009? Is there any reason for division based on race within social groups….in 2009?
I think it’s very simple why I happen to be with a white person: I don’t discriminate based on skin color and my interests fall in line with hers. Very, very simple. No bias, no hatred toward black women or running away from anyone. There just happen to be a lot more white women out there than black, and especially the higher up you go in the economic ladder, they’re even more scarce. So black men are going to be surrounded by more white women than black, and if they don’t care about skin color, they’re going to base their decision on shared interests….not skin color. Does it make sense yet?
Well aware of our history and even spent the time to read one man’s account of this in the book “Why Black Men Love White Women” which was nothing but a pretty decent history lesson of our recent past followed by stereotype after stereotype. But yes, some men choose to stay away from white women because of it and some don’t. Some men use stick deodorant and some use spray. What does that mean though?
This issue has everything to do with either the fear of dating non-blacks or simply that they’re not attracted to them. I think men in general are more broad with their attraction to different types of women, which is why black men have embraced the possibility of being with non-blacks easier than the women. I could be pulling this out of my ass, but it’s just my experience that women are generally more picky with their potential mates, and when you add the element of race into the equation, the pool of mates is narrowed significantly. Black women see this narrow field and want to take their anger out on the black men just because they are more diverse with who they accept as a potential mate. I think that’s completely the wrong attitude to have.
It just comes down to being more open and accepting of other people, and to have people trying to suggest that this is wrong of black men to do is insane.
Again, thanks for the comment.
One thing I must agree with, is your comment that women are more picky than men. lol I couldn’t agree more.
PS please don’t take my posts as an attack. I can get a little argumentative and over the top. I do appreciate your dialogue and look forward to subsequent posts.
Well don’t you think that plays into our dilemma here? When you combine womens’ pickiness with our obsession with race…the end result is that the women that are obsessed with race are going to find fewer compatible partners. This, in turn, might lead to anger and resentment by black women because of how hard it is to find a man and (because they’re obsessed with race) get even more upset when they see a potential mate with someone of another race.
I just can’t help that this entire issue stems from black women either not being open to dating other races or simply not being attracted to other races.
But yeah, I generally give people a little leeway with turning discussions personal before I cut it off. You still had a ways to go before I shut this discussion down since I realize these topics are a little touchy to begin with. Thanks again for commenting.
Ok, so I’m back.
I have to disagree about this issue stemming from Black women and about us being obsessed with race. I don’t think wanting to be with a Black man is being obsessed with race. Some Black women may feel an obligation to Black men, that is not easily forfeited. Be it right or wrong, this makes it difficult to just turn their backs on them.
As for not being willing to date other men, that could be due to many reasons. The most obvious and probably the most relevant is the fact that some Black women aren’t attracted to other men, specifically White men. Or if they are, they are only attracted to a certain type, which renders the others non-existent.
Have you ever wondered why there is such an obligation to a person based on their skin color? Why would you make that automatic distinction that someone with darker skin is in your group?Why do you decide who is in your group, and therefor obligated toward, based on skin color?
Yeah, I agree with you, and I even said this in the article. Black women generally have less in common with white guys for any number of reasons. But I think THAT is the issue here (why black women generally aren’t romantically compatible with other races)and not that black men ARE. If someone can find love or even lust in a wide spectrum of the population, I hardly see that as a problem. Again, it’s called diversity….nature’s best friend.
I know this discussion has been dead for 2 months or so, but I felt compelled to respond. I’m a young black woman who’s grown up mostly around non-black people and considers herself open-minded, resolutely anti-racist and open to relationships with any man, regardless of race.
One criticism I have of this post, which was evident from the start was that it was overly simplistic and defensive. It was clear without you stating that you have been or are in a relationship with a white person, and that more than anything this post was almost like a justification for your relationship history. I’ve always been of the belief that no one needs to justify why they are in a relationship with someone of another race. Of course there are plenty of black men who aren’t attracted to black women or use offensive arguments to justify their attraction to white women. In my opinion, this post seemed like a polite version of the latter.
I think the problem is is that this post underestimated or under states the fact that peoples choices in all aspects of life (not just in the choice of partners) aren’t made in a vacuum. We are all enabled and restricted in the choices that we make by the world that we live in. In respect to the choices that black men and women make in life-partners I think the role of outside views of black men and women play a huge role. Particularly in respect to the attractiveness of black men and women. For one, I think society definately promotes messages that out of the two, black men are more attractive than black women, and we all grow up fully aware of it. A black man who is open to dating interracially will have more success at it than an equally attractive black woman who is equally open to the idea – simply because black women (or the average black woman who doesn’t have European facial features or hair) are not put forward as examples of attractiveness – or at least, not nearly as often as black men with “black” features are. Black women grow up seeing this and I think this knowledge plays a role in making many black women only want black men. Many do believe that in the society that we live in, only black men will ever truly appreciate our beauty (amongst other qualities that are more prevalent in black women).
A great comparison would be the experiences that Asian men vs. Asian women have when dating outside their race, particularly with whites. It is clear from many accounts and research that Asian men are no less open to dating and marrying white women than Asian women are to white men. The reason why Asian men date outside their race in such low numbers is primarily due to how white people view Asian men (I don`t need to go into the negative stereotypes, I`m sure we all know them). I think a similar thing is at play with black men and women.
Also, I would like to point out that just as you have grown up outside the “black community”, there are plenty of black girls who have too grown up outside the traditional “black community” and have grown up interacting with various non-black groups. The argument that that is why you (and by extension other black men) are more open to dating interracial is almost suggesting that that in itself is a reason why so many are open to dating interracially. If that is the case, why aren`t all these black girls doing the same? Believe me, it`s not because they’re not open to it. We are limited by non-black individual’s openness to dating black women. I don`t think black men face nearly the same struggle, as more white women are open to dating black men than white men are to dating black women. Also, lets not forget that as far more black women hold Bachelor degrees than black men, they too are far more likely to interact with white and other non-black men in their daily lives. I truly think that the argument that black women just aren`t open to dating interracially (even though the other black women on this site have conformed to this stereotype) is wiildly overblown. I’ve heard far more black women say they would like to date interracially, but don’t get any interest than black women say they are completely against dating interracially.
Finally, while I agree that if someone decides to shut themselves of from dating other races they shouldn’t get upset when men from their race decide to, I think the reason why many black women do get upset is because too many (not all) black men use the ‘there’s something wrong with black women’ argument to justify their interracial dating. That’s pretty harsh, and you’ll find that white women act in exactly the same way when significant numbers of white men suggest that their attraction to Asian women is due to them being more feminine than white women and ‘knowing how to treat a man’. Considering so many black men (again not all) like to use that argument (or at least are the most vocal) is inevitably going to leave black women feeling like their very existence is threatened by black men dating interracially. Really, it is many different factors coming in to play that have unfortunately left us at this point – and your post seemed to completely ignore the most significant ones.
Josie,
Let me first say that it’s never too late to rehash a topic on this site and thank you for taking the time to respond.
I get a sense that your main beef with my post is that I ignored the fact that the interest in black women on the whole is smaller than the interest in black men. I would definitely agree. But I think you’re moving more into the general topic of interracial dating and I was simply addressing black women’s objections to black men dating “outside of the race”.
I completely agree that, for whatever reason, society devalues the beauty of black women. That’s a completely separate issue than vilifying black men for dating other types of women. Are black women calling black men out because it’s “wrong” to date a white woman, or are they saying it’s “wrong” because they simply don’t have fewer prospects and don’t want to be alone?
I do have to ask you specifically what makes you think this post was just a justification for my actions? In a sense, yes it was. It’s very unfortunate that I have to “justify” very normal behavior nearly the same way someone would have to write an article justifying the acceptance of gay marriage. Of course it’s going to seem like I’m defending myself, because yes, I have to when I’ve been met by people (nearly 100% black by the way) that are against interracial couples. But the way you said it, you made it sound as if I were in the same category as the black men that put down black women to justify their dating white women. How was this post even remotely like that?
This post wasn’t anything about how black women are ugly or have attitudes or anything like that. I have nothing against black women other than their objections to who I choose to be with. I happen to think that this issue is pretty simple to resolve if you just lay it out, which is why I wrote what I did. I just need you to simplify your issues with the post for me a little better to I can address them.
While I will admit that my comment was very much a critique of your post, the reason why I drew your attention to these issues was because I felt that they were some (not all) of the underlying causes of the black female anger at interracial dating.
It may have seemed like my main beef was that you ignored the smaller level of interest in black women from non-black men, but that was only because by ignoring this issue you could never provide a good analysis of why black women are so hostile to black men interracially dating.
I guess I just found the article a little bit frustrating because while it listed all of the various ways in which some black women display their anger at black men dating interracially, it didn’t seem to want to explore a little deeper and analyse the root causes of this anger. It seemed more like you were stating some of the common things that some black women say and feel when they talk about black men dating interracially, rather than why they feel that way. And while, yes there’s nothing wrong with doing that, it would have been a much more nuanced and insightful piece if you had contemplated the underlying causes. There are numerous pieces on this issue on the internet, this post just seemed to rehash a lot of what we’ve heard before and didn’t add anything new to the debate/issue. We’ve all heard the arguments of “them” taking “our men”, but why do black women feel so threatened by non-black women dating black men? I genuinely feel that if there was a plethora of “eligible” black men, more interest from non-black men and there weren’t such high levels of black female singledom a lot of this anger by black women at black male interracial dating would disappear.
And, I continue to believe that it was bordering on the “there’s something wrong with black women” idea, especially when you talked about point no. 2 and why non-black men aren’t as interested in black women and that it was because of an “issue with black women”. Why is it an issue with black women? Why isn’t it equally an issue with white men, asian men, non-black latin men? Can you see why it seemed like you were just pointing the finger at black women?
Furthermore, take note of the point about a so-called larger cultural gap between black women and men of other races than black men and women of other races. I’d be interested to know where you got this theory from, considering, as I pointed out previously, certainly in the sphere of education and employment, black women interact with non-black people at significantly higher rates than black men suggesting that they would have more experience and understanding of non-black cultures. I think it would be a little strange that while interacting more with non-blacks than black men, they somehow still manage to have a larger culture gap. This would probably be the first and only case in the world of that happening.
Also, I did branch out and talk a little about the interracial dating world in general, specifically talking about Asian/white interracial dating because I feel like the parallels between black women and Asian men and how the two groups feel about interracial dating are striking. It seems to show what happens when one gender of the racial group date interracially at significant (or perceived to be significant) numbers and the other half does not itself get a raised interest from outside the racial group – anger and feeling threatened.
And I think you answered your own question when it comes to why it seemed like a justification. It was simply the language used in general and the defensive nature of the post.
Ok, I know I’m starting to ramble now, but also another point I’d like to make is that the reason why near 100% of the people who object to your interracial relationships are black is probably because they’re the only ones who feel that they can freely make such judgements to your face (especially if they’re family members, come on, you know your family would have no problem saying things to you that others wouldn’t – and that includes issues other than race). There are plenty of white and other non-black people who are against interracial dating, they just tend to be less vocal about it (unless of course it’s annoymous).
Ok, I hope that whole piece didn’t come off as hostile. I’m really not, and as I’ve stated before have no problem with you or other black men dating interracially – why should I, it’s none of my business. What I do have a problem with though is when black men complain about this hostility without considering why black women are so hostile. Nonetheless, this hostility should never stop black men from dating some of the lovely women of other races.
Thanks for coming back Josie.
Sure, I’ll admit that this article basically touched on the symptoms of the issue and not the core cause of it. I think I only did that because I’ve moved deeper into issues of race with other posts I’ve made and didn’t want to rehash the same arguments over and over.
You said it yourself that if there were a plethora of black men available, that we wouldn’t have this problem, which is the same thing I said in the article. I’m confused how black men are to be blamed for these issues and not the black women that refuse to date non-blacks.
As I said before, I’ll admit that there is an issue with non-black men and their lack of attraction to black women…but from my experience, the first thing I hear from black women is how they don’t find non-blacks attractive, and not the other way around. In other words, there seems to be an unwillingness among black women to seek out non-black partners for whatever reason. I rarely hear black women say “I’ve tried, and white/asian/latino guys just aren’t into me.”
To me, that’s where our problem begins. There’s a root issue where I think black women feel more tied to their own race than black men. I think a lot of black women just feel race is more important in their lives for whatever reason than black men.
In my 2nd point in the article, I made a point to say that it’s “more of an issue with black women…And I’m not saying that it’s entirely black women’s fault.” Up to this point, the blame has been placed on black men for this entire issue, and what I was trying to say in the 2nd point was that that’s a bit unfair since black women (in my experience) have expressed their unwillingness to date other men. I was simply saying it’s more an issue with black women than it is with black men.
I don’t care how much further black women climb corporately than black men, if they’re less open to dating non-blacks, they’re going to stay shut off. You could be surrounded by non-blacks all day everyday and still maintain the “them versus us” mentality that so many people do. All I’m trying to say is that cultural gaps are closed based on your openness toward other groups and not the time your spend with them…necessarily. You’d think spending time around other groups would close the gap, but some folks are just so set in their ways that no matter how friendly or similar in culture others are, they can’t get past their skin color, so nothing changes. Not saying all black women or even most black women are like this…just most of the ones I’ve come across.
Let me begin by saying I am a white male who is very dismayed by some of the comments I read above. I have been attracted to black women (and every other race of women) since I was old enough to be attracted to women. The sad part is that I grew up in a traditional Italian family (white women were accepted, but Italian was preference), and dating black women was just understood to be “wrong.” Now that I am an adult, I am independent enough to realize just how ignorant, hard-headed and oblivious that sentiment truly is. I am discouraged to see similar sentiments from people’s comments above.
We are America. We all live in the same country. I understand that black-Americans (I say black-American because you may be black and not a descendent of Africa) deal with a lot of stereotypes (more than MOST) throughout the course of their lives, but that really does not make it okay to respond with more racism. Yes, none of you may be willing to admit it, but there were some discouragingly racist statements above. I literally felt inspiration leaving me as I was reading some of them.
Okay, so black-Americans deal and have dealt with a lot of frustrating, and in some cases even inhumane, things throughout their history in this country. I bring this up for one reason, because I want to remind the black-American community that many others deal with stereo-types as well. I’m a short guy, and I GUARANTEE that I hear more slurs throughout the course of my day than any black folks with exception to the most vile, racist areas (West Virginia and others). What is my point? My point is that we all have to deal with adversity throughout our lives. A serious problem I see is that the black community has chosen to separate their adversity from all other adversity. What about overweight people? What about Native Americans (they have dealt with serious atrocities as well)? What about people who are just plain ugly? I think you get my point.
Don’t get me wrong, the segregation of the black communities in the inner-cities is a serious problem, and a terrible injustice in our society. This needs to be addressed immediately, but believe me, it will not get resolved until people of all colors unite as AMERICANS to fix this problem.
I campaigned for Barack Obama to be nominated as the Democratic nominee for President, and then subsequently President. All of his opponents were white men or a white female. Why did I choose to campaign hard for him? Because I felt he was the best INDIVIDUAL for the job. Now that he is the President, I feel as if we could not have found a better role model for AMERICANS of all colors. If I ever have a child one day, I will point to Barack Obama, and tell my child that he is a man to emulate in this world (after myself, of course:-P). His wife is classy, he is classy, and I could give a damn about the color of his skin.
I even defended the Reverend Jeremiah Wright’s insidious comments. I attempted to explain to the white community, which was generally appalled by his statements, that the perspective of a black-American who was raised in 1950s-1960s America is justifiably angry and permanently scarred from what he witnessed. But his generation fought for their rights, so that future generations could have their rights. The future generation has their rights, so for any of them to continue fighting, as if there is a reason to continue fighting, is racist. Should the black community be vigilant, of course, but why not focus your attention on guaranteeing freedom for ALL future generations of Americans.
Playing the victim card is terrible for the human spirit. I understand that there are victims in certain situations, but even in that case, playing that card will not lead to success.
I love when I see black men dating white women, black women dating white men (the “negative” stereotypes mentioned above are untrue and ridiculously absurd) and any other racially diverse couple.
A lot of white men are intimidated by black women. That doesn’t mean it is justified, but I am just keeping it real for all the black women out there. Some white men are not attracted to black women. The reasons for that are unknown to me, but I always assume it is racism, because for someone to say they are “not attracted” to a group of people is outright silly.
Let us just judge INDIVIDUALS.
I ask my black friends out there (male and female) to unite as AMERICANS. Only then will our racial wounds be healed. When we recognize that we all do share the same fate.
The black community may be surprised to hear some of the stories of suffering and adversity that many white folks have to face. I love black people, so do not misinterpret me. Possessing your own culture is great, but limiting yourself to your own culture is ignorant (and it is self-damaging in the long-run).
I hope no one misinterprets my comments. I am as fair as a human being can be. I hate dated more black women than white women. Most black women do not seem to be too judgmental of me.
I am discouraged by some of the racist remarks I have read. Not just in this post, but in many other posts on this website.
Zaki is a friend of mine. He treats me with the utmost respect, and I value the fact that I can speak my mind to him. He doesn’t misinterpret me, and I KNOW he never judges me by my color. So I suggest the people who attacked him for “preaching” and other various things should take a step back, because the guy is on the right track.
The election of Barack Obama proved that a black-America CAN ascend to the highest office of the land. That does not mean racism is over, believe me, I understand that, but it did prove that an individual can overcome event he most difficult adversities in our society.
:~) <— that’s me crying tears of joy by the way
“I hate dated more black women than white women. Most black women do not seem to be too judgmental of me.”
In that comment made above, the “I hate dated more black women….” was supposed to be “I have dated more black women.”
Hahahaha, an awkward typo.
what i dont understand is you often hear critique of black women whether constructive or not from black men who claim to be interested in women of other races. so why care about what the black woman is doing?? just the fact that the author has the need to post his topic about race is evidence that he has issues with his race. I don’t think I have ever read so so many posts by white women that critique about white men addressed to white men. But for black men who date non black women you can find many posts, videos, speeches, whatever. Maybe black women take offense because she constantly have to defend her very existence on the regular, and you black guys are so “in your face” with the fact that you have someone that is not a black woman in your arms. It sort of like Rosie O’Donnell’s “yes, I’m gay what are you going to do about it” mode versus Ellen’s coming out. Sometimes it’s how you say things that make people offended and most of the time black men with there interracial blog is usually pointing flaws at black women or how unworthy black women are compared to other races of women. That is unfair, and I wish for once black men knew what it felt like.
Similar to how you just responded to my blog post, my blog post was my reaction to hearing people discuss the issue of interracial dating. I have heard black women say each of the things I pointed out in the above post, and chose this forum to discuss them. I see nothing wrong with that.
I need not have a problem with “my race” to discuss others’ issue with my race or the race of my fiance or anyone else for that matter. I could care less what race anyone is, including myself, since I don’t judge people, including myself, based on skin color. This blog post was simply my reaction to OTHER PEOPLE’S reaction to my actions and the actions of other people that choose to ignore race when choosing a mate. That is all.
Mr. Zaki
Most black men who date non black women for some reason have to let it be known that they have a woman that is not black. I really find that peculiar because most of the nagging of these men are mostly directed to either black women or the black community as a whole or both. Believe it or not despite how many stares you claim you have because you have a snow bunny on your arms the black community as a whole is more accepting of different races into the family. I think you should direct your interracial speeches to that of the Caucasian community where generally it is not accepting to bring a black man to the family when you compare between the two races….. and God forbid if she is a black woman. The “why do black women have problems with me dating a woman of another race” is NOTHING NEW and kind of PLAYED OUT. Everybody knows that black men are attracted to women of other races and EVERYBODY knows that black men date/marry women of other races. If you ask me, it sounds as if you are rubbing it in as if its some prize piece that you chosen white meat instead of dark, it seems as if you want some sort of reaction from black women because of the decision you made. Well, I can tell you this if you keep nagging and dragging this issue on and on and on you are bound to get some negative post. And actually in a way, I think that is what you are looking for, so you can say “I told you so.” That said Mr. Zaki, again black men with nonblack women is becoming such a standard everyday relationship, it is starting to no longer raise an eyebrow anymore. Do you know what is not normal these days?? A black man with a black woman and they are head over heels in love with one another…